Voter guide · Nov 3, 2026
Smithfield Town Council Election 2026
4 of 7 council seats are on the ballot, with 5 candidates running. Updated Oct 9, 2026. Every claim links to its source. How we check
Not sure who to vote for? Answer 5 questions and see which candidates agree with you, and why.
No sign-in. Your answers stay on your device. We never endorse anyone.
How to vote · 11 days left
Election Day (Nov 3): the election office's noticeThese links go to official state and county election sites. Hours and rules differ by state; your election office has the final word.
The candidates
Listed alphabetically by last name. Every position links to its source.
Town Council
Vote for up to 4- Jeff D. BrooksIncumbentTown Council member; first elected in 20229sourced
- Valerie Cofer ButlerIncumbentTown Council member; first elected in 20188sourced
- Nicholas F. HessOwner of the Gatling Pointe Yacht Club and chairman of Smithfield's Board of Zoning Appeals.6sourced
- A. Russ MacConnellFormer vice president of the Cypress Creek Homeowners Association in Smithfield.7sourced
- Gene S. Monroe Jr.NASA Langley Research Center retiree and vice chairman of Smithfield's Board of Zoning Appeals.6sourced
Voters can choose up to four of the five Town Council candidates, and the top four vote-getters win; three other council members continue in office.
Also on your Nov 3 ballot
We research city races only. For these races, go to the state's official guide or a nonpartisan one.
- U.S. Senate
- Mark R. Warner · Democratic
- Bert Mizusawa · Republican
- U.S. HouseDistrict 2
- Statewide measures3 on the ballot: the state's official explanations
Districts come from 2020 Census blocks and the district maps for this election. Your address decides your districts.
Already on the council, not on the ballot
Whoever you elect will govern alongside these members.
- Mary Ellen BebermeyerCouncil member; elected in 20243sourced
- Darren CutlerCouncil member; elected in 20244sourced
- Michael G. SmithMayor; chosen by the council in January 20253sourced
Officeholders' pages compare what they've said with how they've voted, with sources.
What the next council decides
01Growth and housing density4 sourced facts
Where it standsThe council has debated written guidance asking the Planning Commission not to change zoning in ways that increase density.
What's on the tableThe next council will decide how far special use permits can be used to allow more homes on a property.
- On July 7, 2026 Councilman Darren Cutler presented a five-point draft of written guidance to the Planning Commission on growth and development. Smithfield Times · Jul 13, 2026
- On August 4, 2026 the council voted 7-0 to table the guidance. Smithfield Town Council minutes, August 4, 2026 · Aug 4, 2026
- The September 1, 2026 council agenda listed a motion to adopt Planning Commission guidance from the Town Council. Smithfield Town Council agenda, September 1, 2026 · Sep 1, 2026
- As of August 2026 the Planning Commission had yet to vote on proposed special use permit waivers that included maximum density. Smithfield Times · Aug 6, 2026
02Pierceville property4 sourced facts
Where it standsThe town bought the 57 acres at Route 10 and Main Street for $6.5 million and rezoned the land to community conservation.
What's on the tableThe next council will choose a master-plan consultant and decide how the land is used.
- On March 3, 2026 the council voted 6-1 to approve buying the property from LSMP, LLC for $6.5 million, with Valerie Butler voting no. Smithfield Town Council minutes, March 3, 2026 · Mar 3, 2026
- On May 5, 2026 the council voted 6-1 to approve a $6.7 million bond for the purchase. Smithfield Town Council minutes, May 5, 2026 · May 5, 2026
- On October 7, 2026 the council voted unanimously to rezone the land to community conservation, the town's most restrictive zoning district. Smithfield Times · Oct 8, 2026
- The town's request for master-planning proposals lists possible uses including a new municipal building, a farmers market and public green space. Smithfield Times · Oct 8, 2026
03License plate cameras3 sourced facts
Where it standsSmithfield police operate 16 leased Flock license plate cameras.
What's on the tableThe next council will decide whether to keep paying for the cameras and what limits to set on their use.
- The town's 16 Flock cameras captured over 1.6 million images in July 2026. Smithfield Times · Aug 18, 2026
- On August 4, 2026 the council unanimously approved a consent agenda that included a $33,000 invoice from Flock Safety. Smithfield Town Council minutes, August 4, 2026 · Aug 4, 2026
- A state law in effect since July 1, 2025 requires agencies to purge the data after 21 days unless it is tied to an active criminal investigation or civil action. Smithfield Times · Aug 18, 2026
04Closed-session records2 sourced facts
Where it standsSince March 2026 the council has not kept minutes or recordings of its closed sessions.
What's on the tableThe next council can keep that policy or restore closed-session minutes.
- On March 3, 2026 the council voted 6-1 to stop taking minutes or recordings of closed sessions, with Darren Cutler voting no. Smithfield Town Council minutes, March 3, 2026 · Mar 3, 2026
- The interim town attorney said he was not aware of any other governing body that kept closed-session minutes. Smithfield Town Council minutes, March 3, 2026 · Mar 3, 2026
05Short-term rentals3 sourced facts
Where it standsHomeowners may rent their homes short-term for up to 104 nights a year by right; more nights require a special use permit from the council.
What's on the tableThe next council will decide permit requests for year-round short-term rentals and whether to change the rules.
- Smithfield's zoning ordinance allows short-term rental of a home by right for up to 104 nights per calendar year. Smithfield Times · Mar 2, 2026
- The town had at least nine short-term rentals in early 2026, four of them permitted to exceed the 104-night limit. Smithfield Times · Mar 2, 2026
- Town tourism staff said a cap of 0.5% of the population would allow up to 33 additional short-term rentals. Smithfield Times · Mar 2, 2026
2 notes on these statements
Vice Mayor Bill Harris and Councilman Steve Bowman hold two of the four seats on the ballot and are not running. Smithfield Times · Jun 19, 2026
Nicholas F. Hess and Gene S. Monroe Jr. are chairman and vice chairman of the town's Board of Zoning Appeals. Smithfield Times · Jun 19, 2026
No sign-in · answers stay on your phone
Who matches you?
Answer any of these questions. We compare your answers with each person's sourced record, and nothing is stored. Questions where no one has a sourced record yet are left out. Tap a selected answer again to skip it.
1. Should developers be able to get special use permits that raise housing density?
2. Was the town right to buy the Pierceville property for $6.5 million?
3. Should Smithfield police keep using Flock license plate cameras?
4. Should the council keep minutes of its closed sessions?
5. Should Smithfield allow more short-term rentals?
Key dates
- Early voting beginsSmithfield Times · Sep 1, 2026Sep 18, 2026
- Election DaySmithfield Times · Sep 1, 2026Nov 3, 2026
The seat math
3 stay (not up this year): Mary Ellen Bebermeyer, Darren Cutler, Michael G. Smith4 on this ballot
7 council seats. The council decides by a 4-vote majority.
- The mayor is not elected directly by voters but by a majority vote of the sitting council members every two years. Smithfield Times · Jan 8, 2025
- All Town Council candidates run at-large, and the top four vote-getters will be elected. Smithfield Times · Jun 19, 2026
- Town Council members serve four-year terms. Virginia Department of Elections
- The town manager is Michael R. Stallings, Jr. Town of Smithfield
Every claim here links to its source and was checked against it before publishing. How this guide works
See something wrong? Report an error
Something wrong or missing? Tell us what and where, with a link to a source if you have one. Reports feed the next verification run.