Voter guide · Nov 3, 2026
Olean Common Council Election 2026
3 of 7 council seats are on the ballot, with 4 candidates running. Updated Oct 5, 2026. Every claim links to its source. How we check
Not sure who to vote for? Answer 5 questions and see which candidates agree with you, and why.
No sign-in. Your answers stay on your device. We never endorse anyone.
How to vote · 11 days left
These links go to official state and county election sites. Hours and rules differ by state; your election office has the final word.
The candidates
Listed alphabetically by last name. Every position links to its source.
Alderman Ward 1
UnopposedAlderman Ward 3
1 seatOlean has seven wards; voters in Wards 1, 3 and 5 each choose one alderman for their own ward. The mayor is not on this ballot.
Also on your Nov 3 ballot
We research city races only. For these races, go to the state's official guide or a nonpartisan one.
- Governor
- Kathy C. Hochul · Democratic, Working Families
- Bruce A. Blakeman · Republican, Conservative, Vote Affordable
- Also statewideComptroller · Attorney General
- U.S. HouseDistrict 23
- State SenateDistrict 57
- State AssemblyDistrict 148
Districts come from 2020 Census blocks and the district maps for this election. Your address decides your districts.
Already on the council, not on the ballot
Whoever you elect will govern alongside these members.
David AnastasiaAlderman, Ward 7; term ends December 20277sourced
Joseph KearyAlderman, Ward 2; term ends December 20276sourced
Sonya McCallAlderman, Ward 4; term ends December 20273sourced
- Amy B. SherburneMayor of Oleanbio only
Officeholders' pages compare what they've said with how they've voted, with sources.
What the next council decides
01Security cameras2 sourced facts
Where it standsThe council approved a Verkada camera agreement in September 2026 but a $275,000 bond to pay for it failed.
What's on the tableWhether and how the city funds and expands a security camera system.
- On September 8, 2026 the council approved an agreement with Verkada for security cameras and ten years of licensing by a 4-2 vote. Olean Common Council minutes, Sept. 8, 2026 · Sep 8, 2026
- A bond resolution for up to $275,000 for security cameras failed 4-2 because it needed a two-thirds vote of all council members, including the vacant seat. Olean Common Council minutes, Sept. 8, 2026 · Sep 8, 2026
02Property-tax cap and budget2 sourced facts
Where it standsThe council overrode the state property-tax levy limit for the 2026-27 fiscal year.
What's on the tableHow the next budget handles taxes and the state levy limit.
- The local law applies to the budget for the fiscal year beginning June 1, 2026 and ending May 31, 2027. Olean Common Council minutes, Apr. 14, 2026 · Apr 14, 2026
- The local law requires approval by at least sixty percent of the Common Council. Olean Common Council minutes, Apr. 14, 2026 · Apr 14, 2026
03Olean Center Mall2 sourced facts
Where it standsIn January 2026 the council acted on eminent domain findings for the mall property on North Union Street.
What's on the tableHow the city follows up on the narrowed property interests it moved to acquire.
- The properties are at 400, 420 and 450 N. Union Street. Olean Common Council minutes, Jan. 13, 2026 · Jan 13, 2026
- The council's findings describe the project as limited to acquiring the Narrowed Proposed Interests. Olean Common Council minutes, Jan. 13, 2026 · Jan 13, 2026
04Wayne Street path2 sourced facts
Where it standsThe council voted 6-0 in September 2026 to end the Wayne Street Shared Use Path project.
What's on the tableWhich city funds will close out the project and repay the state.
- The City Auditor said reimbursing NYS-DOT would cost $36,963.33 and making Capital Fund 241 whole would cost $62,776.64. Olean Common Council minutes, Sept. 8, 2026 · Sep 8, 2026
- The council's resolution says the city's required contribution was in great excess of the original budgeted amount. Olean Common Council minutes, Sept. 8, 2026 · Sep 8, 2026
05Recreation Center pool1 sourced fact
Where it standsThe council awarded a $1,093,377 pool upgrades construction contract in July 2026.
What's on the tableFurther pool repair decisions and how they are paid for.
- The bid opened April 22, 2026 and the city's engineer, Clark Patterson Lee, recommended Patterson-Stevens, Inc. of Tonawanda. Olean Common Council minutes, July 28, 2026 · Jul 28, 2026
2 notes on these statements
The Ward 3 and Ward 5 seats are held by Jennifer Forney and John Crawford, whose terms expire December 2026. City of Olean
City Attorney Bridget Marshall referred to a vacant Alderman seat at the September 8, 2026 council meeting. Olean Common Council minutes, Sept. 8, 2026 · Sep 8, 2026
No sign-in · answers stay on your phone
Who matches you?
Answer any of these questions. We compare your answers with each person's sourced record, and nothing is stored. Questions where no one has a sourced record yet are left out. Tap a selected answer again to skip it.
1. How should Olean handle a citywide security camera system?
2. Should the council override the state property-tax cap when it adopts a budget?
3. How should the city use eminent domain at the Olean Center Mall?
4. The Wayne Street shared-use path cost far more than budgeted. What should the city do?
5. What should the city do about repairing the Recreation Center pool?
Key dates
The seat math
4 stay (not up this year): David Anastasia, Joseph Keary, Sonya McCall, Amy B. Sherburne3 on this ballot
7 council seats. The council decides by a 4-vote majority.
- The Common Council has seven wards, each with one alderman. City of Olean
- The Wards 1, 3 and 5 terms expire in December 2026; the Wards 2, 4 and 7 terms expire in December 2027. City of Olean
- JR Bennion of Ward 1 is the Council President. City of Olean
- The mayor is elected by voters: the 2025 county certification listed a citywide Mayor contest, vote for one. Cattaraugus County Board of Elections · Aug 12, 2025
- Bond resolutions need a two-thirds vote of all council members, counting a vacant seat. Olean Common Council minutes, Sept. 8, 2026 · Sep 8, 2026
Every claim here links to its source and was checked against it before publishing. How this guide works
See something wrong? Report an error
Something wrong or missing? Tell us what and where, with a link to a source if you have one. Reports feed the next verification run.