Voter guide · Nov 3, 2026
Garwood Mayor & Borough Council Election 2026
3 of 6 council seats are on the ballot, with 8 candidates running. Updated Oct 20, 2026. Every claim links to its source. How we check
Not sure who to vote for? Answer 4 questions and see which candidates agree with you, and why.
No sign-in. Your answers stay on your device. We never endorse anyone.
How to vote · 11 days left
Early voting begins (Oct 24): the election office's noticeThese links go to official state and county election sites. Hours and rules differ by state; your election office has the final word.
The candidates
Listed alphabetically by last name. Every position links to its source.
Mayor
1 seatBorough Council
Vote for up to 2- Karina BotoIncumbentGarwood Council President and Finance Committee chair; on the Borough Council since 2024.9sourced
- Brenda CaffreyRepublican candidate for a three-year seat on the Garwood Borough Council.1sourced
- Laura Spina-ThompsonRepublican candidate for a three-year seat on the Garwood Borough Council.5sourced
- Brian TaguePortfolio oversight manager at Bank of America Private Bank and Garwood Recreation Committee member.5sourced
Voters choose a mayor for a four-year term, two at-large council members for three-year terms, and one council member for an unexpired term; the mayor votes only to break ties.
Also on your Nov 3 ballot
We research city races only. For these races, go to the state's official guide or a nonpartisan one.
- U.S. Senate
- Cory Booker · Democratic
- Justin Murphy · Republican
- Veronica Fernandez · End the Corruption!
- Joanne Kuniansky · Socialist Workers Party
Districts come from 2020 Census blocks and the district maps for this election. Your address decides your districts.
Already on the council, not on the ballot
Whoever you elect will govern alongside these members.
- Kathleen AnnarelliCouncilwoman; term ends December 20286sourced
- Clarissa NoldeCouncilwoman; term ends December 20285sourced
- Chase PadusniakCouncilman; term ends December 20274sourced
Officeholders' pages compare what they've said with how they've voted, with sources.
What the next council decides
01Paperboard redevelopment and affordable housing4 sourced facts
Where it standsIn March 2026 the council adopted an amended Paperboard Redevelopment Plan for 75 North Avenue under a court-approved affordable housing settlement, and in September it approved a second amendment to the developer agreement.
What's on the tableThe next council will oversee the project as it moves through site-plan review and a financial agreement with the developer.
- A March 25, 2025 court order set Garwood's fourth-round affordable housing obligation at 31 present-need units and 80 prospective-need units. Borough of Garwood · Mar 12, 2026
- The borough, Garwood Paperboard and Fair Share Housing Center resolved challenges to the borough's housing plan through a settlement agreement filed January 22, 2026. Borough of Garwood · Mar 12, 2026
- The borough's redevelopment attorney said the settlement eliminated the commercial component of the redevelopment. Borough of Garwood · Sep 24, 2026
- The final density of the project is 45 units per acre, and it must still go through site-plan review and a financial agreement. Borough of Garwood · Jan 6, 2026
02Flooding and the sewer system3 sourced facts
Where it standsThe mayor asked the council to fund an engineering study of the sewer system in the 2026 budget, and a retention basin study is forthcoming.
What's on the tableThe next council will decide which flood projects to pay for once the studies are done.
- Mayor Jen Blumenstock asked the council to fund an engineering study of the sewer system to identify potential flood solutions. Borough of Garwood · Jan 6, 2026
- The mayor said larger regional flood solutions have proven difficult without federal funding. Borough of Garwood · Jan 6, 2026
- The council said a retention basin study is forthcoming. Borough of Garwood · Jan 22, 2026
03Budget and taxes3 sourced facts
Where it standsThe council adopted the 2026 municipal budget in May 2026 after line-by-line review by its Finance Committee.
What's on the tableThe next council will write the 2027 budget within the state's caps on spending and the tax levy.
- The council adopted the 2026 municipal budget 5-0 on May 14, 2026, with one member absent. Borough of Garwood · May 14, 2026
- A motion to add $7,000 to the Fire Department's proposed 2026 budget failed 2-4. Borough of Garwood · Apr 7, 2026
- The borough administrator wrote that municipalities are limited by a 2% levy cap. Borough of Garwood · Apr 9, 2026
04Paid parking2 sourced facts
Where it standsIn August 2026 the council amended the borough's paid parking rules to allow free parking from December 15 to January 1.
What's on the tableThe next council will set paid parking rules and fees.
- The mayor said Ordinance 26-17 allows free parking from December 15 to January 1. Borough of Garwood · Aug 13, 2026
- The council adopted Ordinance 26-17 by a 3-1 vote on August 13, 2026. Borough of Garwood · Aug 13, 2026
05Street safety and sidewalks2 sourced facts
Where it standsGarwood is adding sidewalks along South Avenue and repaving streets with state grants.
What's on the tableThe next council will choose road, sidewalk and traffic-safety projects and apply for grants to pay for them.
- Mayor Jen Blumenstock said sidewalks will be added along South Avenue so the entire length of the street through Garwood is walkable. Borough of Garwood · Jan 6, 2026
- The borough was awarded a $322,825 NJDOT grant for resurfacing parts of Second Avenue and Willow Avenue and for South Avenue sidewalks. Borough of Garwood · Dec 4, 2025
2 notes on these statements
Councilman Hursh Sureka was appointed in January 2026 to fill a vacancy for a term running through certification of the November 3, 2026 election results. Borough of Garwood · Jan 22, 2026
Stephanie Bianco was appointed in December 2025 to fill a vacancy for a term running through certification of the November 3, 2026 election results. Borough of Garwood · Dec 4, 2025
No sign-in · answers stay on your phone
Who matches you?
Answer any of these questions. We compare your answers with each person's sourced record, and nothing is stored. Questions where no one has a sourced record yet are left out. Tap a selected answer again to skip it.
1. How should Garwood proceed with housing on the former Paperboard site at 75 North Avenue?
2. How should Garwood respond to flooding?
3. Should downtown parking be free during the December holidays?
4. How should Garwood make its streets safer?
Key dates
- Voter registration deadlineUnion County ClerkOct 13, 2026
- Early voting begins (through Nov. 1)Union County ClerkOct 24, 2026
- Last day to apply by mail for a mail-in ballotUnion County ClerkOct 27, 2026
- General election day (polls 6 a.m. to 8 p.m.)Union County ClerkNov 3, 2026
The seat math
3 stay (not up this year): Kathleen Annarelli, Clarissa Nolde, Chase Padusniak3 on this ballot
6 council seats plus a mayor who doesn't vote on council items. The council decides by a 4-vote majority.
- Garwood uses the borough form of government: a mayor elected to a four-year term and six council members elected to staggered three-year terms, with two seats up each year. Wikipedia
- The mayor presides at council meetings and votes only in the event of a tie. Wikipedia
- The governing body is elected by the citizens at large. Borough of Garwood
- Mayor Jen Blumenstock's term ends December 31, 2026. Wikipedia
- The 2026 ballot has a mayor contest, two Members of Council seats with three-year terms, and one Member of Council seat for an unexpired term. Union County Clerk · Sep 3, 2026
Every claim here links to its source and was checked against it before publishing. How this guide works
See something wrong? Report an error
Something wrong or missing? Tell us what and where, with a link to a source if you have one. Reports feed the next verification run.